OPINION

Organ Donation - Harvesting Spare Parts

May 08, 2008
Shantanu Dutta

Many years ago, there used to be a minister in West Bengal Chief Minister Jyoti Basu’s cabinet by the name of Benoy Choudhury. He used to be the deputy chief minister at one point and was responsible for all the land reforms carried out in the early years of the Left Front government. An austere, honest and humble man in life, he stayed that way in death. When he died, there was neither cremation nor burial - he had donated his remains to the government medical college so that students might learn some anatomy by dissecting up his body.

Recently, A.K.Antony set another sort of precedent when he donated his organs as did celebrities Priyanka Chopra and cricketer Navjot Singh Sidhu. Preity Zinta has done this even earlier. This is great. For just as it is desirable to avoid ostentatious ness in the happier moments of life, so too in moments of grief – especially when there is a lot that could be done with our bodies even after we have passed on. As Priyanka Chopra put it quite well, in a symbolic sense, donating your organs enables you to live for ever.

But while such romantic notions of eternity are fine; there is a case to revisit the entire gamut of organ donation in the country. For on one side, there is a scarcity of vital organs so much so that there is a thriving black market in them and on the other side, every such organs are being consigned to the flames or buried six feet under.

As Scott Carney writes in Wired magazine,

Scarcity has long been a key driver of the global kidney market, but in regions like India, Brazil, Pakistan and China, sellers are dealing with signs of a surplus. Operations that once set back patients tens of thousands of dollars on the black market can now be had for a fraction of the cost in some places.” and body brokers are now connecting wealthy patients with healthy but poor people willing to sell their organs for cash. The international market for human parts is thriving: A kidney goes for $25,000 in Russia, a heart for $290,000 in South Africa

In organ donation, the main taboos seem to be religious and here it does not seem to make much of a difference as to which religion one belongs to. But the taboos are clearly relative. The large numbers of donors who are poor and living on the edge who are selling of their organs for a pittance clearly are prepared to sell to survive another day. The presence of affluent doctors like Amit Kumar acting as racketeers and brokers proves that religious taboos are not too binding at the rich end of society either.

Not too long ago, blood donation was handicapped by similar taboos and myths. Now while it may be a little premature to claim that all the taboos have gone away, it goes without saying that we have come a long way indeed. Though fringes of commercialism still persist in the form of the “professional blood donors”, the voluntary blood donor movement – aided by strong social backing and helpful legislation has grown. Perhaps, we need to go the same route for harvesting our organs and who knows the large catchments of voluntary blood donors who already know what it means to gift life through donating blood may become the bulwark of another movement – those who donate blood in life…. And their body parts in death…

Shantanu Dutta is a medical doctor by training and a development professional by vocation. His writings mostly deal with change, complexity and conversion and tries to look at a changing world through heaven's eyes.
eXTReMe Tracker
Keep reading for comments on this article and add some feedback of your own!

Comments! Feedback! Speak and be heard!

Comment on this article or leave feedback for the author

#1
annamma
May 9, 2008
11:35 AM

Blood donation is okay, because one can do it while living. But talking about death, and what should be done with one's body after one dies - the general Indian public is still far away from that. Talking about death is almost like a bad omen. Its not done, its avoided, quite often; so much so that many, many people do not like to tell their terminally ill relatives that they are dying. "Whats the use" they say; "The person will not be able to take it" they feel. So we see these cancer patients and their relatives all pretending that everything is okay, and the patient is going to get better soon... talking about donating one's organs, which implies first facing up to the prospect of death in an open fashion - very few are there, realy.

Folks on desicritics should be there, though - so lets all tell our closest relative/ spouse that we'd like our body organs to be donated when we die. Next time we go to the hospital for a cough/ cold, maybe we can just enquire about the relevant forms and sign them!!

#2
shantanu dutta
May 9, 2008
09:29 PM

http://www.ebai.org/html/eyepledgeform.asp - on line site for pledging eyes.

Add your comment

(Or ping: http://desicritics.org/tb/7679)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.






Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!