Desicritics Comments on Narendra Modi and Adolf Hitler

Comment by Ereninhelia

Sun, 8 Jun 2008 14:45:39 EDT

[url=http://peters.blogsome.com]buyer cash jewelry[/url] taxco sterling silver jewelry vintage http://zhurnal.journalspace.com

Comment by Amit Patel

Thu, 10 Jan 2008 09:09:33 EST

That is not Gandhi Way. Gandhi died and Naththuram killed.

Comment by Ledzius

Thu, 10 Jan 2008 08:39:49 EST

No, I think he was talking about a suicide bomber wearing an explosive belt.

Comment by Amit Patel

Thu, 10 Jan 2008 08:34:21 EST

Every right minded person should join BJP and clean it from inside. Here is the link. WWW.BJP.ORG

Comment by Gill

Thu, 10 Jan 2008 08:21:14 EST

lomi wrote "If he does, Allah will kill him into pieces." What Allah has a chop shop??? I thought Allah was mercifull but I guess I was wrong!!!

Comment by lomi

Thu, 10 Jan 2008 05:58:57 EST

very informative article. Modi is digging his grave. He is not going to go that far. If he does, Allah will kill him into pieces.

Comment by Sonny

Thu, 10 Jan 2008 01:55:51 EST

[edited]

Comment by kerty

Sun, 30 Dec 2007 14:10:19 EST

Amit.. Congratulation for winning the case. I knew I never had a fighting chance. I blame it on my lack of schooling. I could not develop my IQ beyond single digit.

Comment by Amit Patel

Sun, 30 Dec 2007 12:01:08 EST

Kerty, So now you have spoken, the trut feeling of BJP. I rest my case.

Comment by kerty

Sun, 30 Dec 2007 11:55:55 EST

Amit.. In the last meeting of BJP inner circle at 10 Janpath, we discussed about adopting Bhagvad Gita as Indian constitution, and Manu as common civil laws, VHP as judiciary, Bajarang Dal as law enforcement, Shiv Sena as Indian army. We figured that as soon as Modi has completed his Nazi progrom on Moslems and christians, BJP will be able to deliver Hindu nation. We also talked about what to do with Gandians like Amit. The inner circle was unanimous that Hinsa would be appropriate and many volunteered to raise army of Godse in each localities. In the next meeting of inner circle, we are going to discuss the time table for implementing our first 5 year Yogana. So stay tuned. But keep this confidential, we don't want Sujai to know, he will only leak it to media and Sonia which would spoil our secret party plans. If you want to join the inner circle as special guest of honor, the price is only 5.5 crore - we don't call it corruption because party needs funds to build Hindu nation and UPA has made everything so expensive.

Comment by Amit Patel

Sun, 30 Dec 2007 09:52:26 EST

Kerty, So tell me when will BJP will be success full in delivering HINDU nation to its followers. Isn't that what they are talking about in BJP inner circles?

Comment by kerty

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 14:22:27 EST

Amit "And I don't respect people who are "Dag" on the fundamental Hindu principals." I don't see your famous love oozing out there. Besides, you seem to be confused between fundamental Gandhian principles and fundamental Hindu principles - but that is your choice. But don't expect or be bewildered that everybody else would share your confusion. People have to live and deal with real world, not some fantasy world of fake idealism. On issue of Ayodhya Rama Mandir, you don't even have clue how political process works and what kind of political realities exist in India to tackle issues like these - being in power does not mean acting like Nazi or doing dictatorship or playing roughshod over democratic institutions - It is about building consensus, mobilizing and uniting people, consulting coalition partners and taking into account their concerns, removing political opposition and legal hurdles - all of that need political will that needs to be created thru political process and democratic means, and therefore issue has to remain on political agenda and progress will be bumpy and slow depending on resolve of political opposition - some issues may have to take back seat because there is no consensus among coalition partners and political opposition may be insurmountable given razor this majority - slow progress on issues like Ram Mandir or uniform civil code or scrapping of article 356 is a reflection on resolve of political opposition and not political resolve of BJP - Ram Mandir is not about just building a concrete structure there, it is also about reconstructing political realities and it has to be done democratically - it shows how little you know about political realities or care about this issue and you claim to be a proud hindu. Come on now. None of us were born yesterday. If you are truely a Gandhian, you should look within why they have become such a laughing stock.

Comment by commonsenseforall77

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 12:51:12 EST

Amit, Well said. Why did the BJP not build the ram mandir. why did they not push thru the civil code? because all these issues were mere ploys to come to power and need to be on the back-burner for later when they are out of power. and they desperately try to claim that they speak for all hindus! the same logic or lack thereof at work with all fundmamentalists, muslims, christians and what have you...

Comment by Amit Patel

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 11:40:18 EST

Kerty # 134, Sorry Kerty I have love and respect all including those who do not respect me...as long as that person is at least Human. I do not have any hate for them but no respect either. I am Hindu my self very proud Hindu. And I don't respect people who are "Dag" on the fundamental Hindu principals. If you want to win election use any means possible. But do not use Hindu extremism. Please leave Hinduism alone. To all Hindus who believed BJP during ayodhya adhyay; BJP was in power for 19 month in 1989 ( with VP Singh / Chandra Shekhar) , 15 days in May 1996 (Atal Behari Vajpayee) and full 62 months term in 1998 (Atal Behari Vajpayee). Why they did not built "Ram Mandir". Hinduism is just a ploy to get power. Get in inner circle of BJP and you will find the truth.

Comment by Amit Patel

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 11:02:22 EST

Kerty # 134.
But why modi hires all NON GUJARATIS for these position. Does he think that he can not find better candidate from Gujarat

Comment by razorMirage

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 04:46:46 EST

#146. sq....u dint get my comments right....I said why people are seeing the result(Modi) and not the cause (pan-Hindu support globally). So the issue is why Hindus are supporting leaders like Modi? And NOT why Modi is getting support.

Comment by kerty

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 04:34:42 EST

Common Sense #148/149 I asked you those rhetorical questions because you called it sophistry when I made similar comments in some other thread about 'hate of hatred' not being morally equivallent with hatred. I have no issue with secular humanism as long as it remains your personal ideology in your private space. When you bring it out in "public sphere" or seek to elevate it as state's ideology, I would like to use some of the arguments you used in #148

Comment by commonsenseforall77@yahoo.com

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 04:07:22 EST

Kerty wrote: "What is your justification for your hatred of hate-mongers? Are you justifying your hatred because hate-mongers promote hate? And why is that not sophistry?" Your query is akin to: "Buddha said we must get rid of all desires. But to get rid of all desires is itself another desire. Hence the desire to get rid of desires is not a valid proposition". We are talking across each other, so please be happy in your own desires and views. I sincerely wish you all the best.

Comment by commonsenseforall77@yahoo.com

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 04:01:17 EST

Kerty, Good attempt there, but: to hate hate-mongers is a necessary and sufficient condition to end hate. As in secular humanism, which, surprise surprise, I subscribe to, without apologies. You are free to believe in anything as long as you do not mess up my life in the "public sphere". Do what you want, with your religion and your imagined support of imgagined communities, but please restrict to your own private space. So, if I hate hate-mongers, I am trying to create a zone where no hate for any commmunity/religion is allowed. Do you recognize your sophistry here? As in "All Greeks are liars, said Plato". So, Plato was a Greek. So was he a liar? And so on and so forth. Sooner or later, the game, be it Greek or Indian, Muslim, Christian or Hindu, ceases to be worth the candle! My, no doubt utopian ideal, does not apologize for any group, community or creed. Instead, I seek to apply a "crap detector" ( Ernest Hemingway's words) to every idea that needs it....regardless of whether it is the jehadists/the parivar/the missionaries/the nationalists/the patriots/ or whoever is deluded into believing that they represent someone else while leaving a trail of blood and hatred while pretending that they are doing it for the "common good" although it is a partisan commitment.

Comment by commonsenseforall77@yahoo.com

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 04:01:13 EST

Comment by smallsquirrel

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 03:58:00 EST

razor.. no I got it and I did not make a straight comparison... I simply said that like one would look at one situation (you can insert ANY political figure there) one should look at Modi's rise in the same way. seems you, actually, did not get MY comment

Comment by razorMirage

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 03:44:55 EST

smallsquirrel... hmm...you got it partially... I said "Not only in Gujarat...he is great Hero even in edjucated, high-earninig Hindus?" So comparision of Hitler is ruled out. Moving further lets talk some thing new and original.

Comment by Kerty

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 03:37:05 EST

Commonsense..137 What is your justification for your hatred of hate-mongers? Are you justifying your hatred because hate-mongers promote hate? And why is that not sophistry?

Comment by smallsquirrel

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 03:28:43 EST

razor... very good point. in order to understand hitler and how what he did was possible we must understand post WWI Germany and what conditions led to the climate that made his rise to power possible. In the same way, we should look at why Gujarat seems to think Modi is right for them, and what conditions have let to this. how very very right you are.

Comment by razorMirage

Sat, 29 Dec 2007 03:20:26 EST

The greatness of this man is the more you (hype and) bash the more powerful he is becoming. I guess, forget Congress even Media is clueless how to counter him. Not sure what strategy he uses after 5 years.But I am sure people who write these articles and comment against him are just falling into his set-up. As long these people are active and barking(sorry for this word, but this is nessasary to give good picture of what people, media, etc are doing to Modi) then Modi is safe. I always say/ask, instead of targeting him....people shd start thinking why people are for him. Not only in Gujarat...he is great Hero even in edjucated, high-earninig Hindus? People are seeing the result but not the cause.