OPINION

Indian First, Tamilians Second

April 01, 2007
Wondering Man

While reading reports of a recent round of four Indian fishermen being killed by the Sri Lankan forces (or at the hands of LTTE), I found that many of them state that those who lost their lives were 'Tamil fishermen'. Those reports that focused on the 'Tamil Fishermen' angle went on to explain how the ruling Tamil Nadu Government and DMK supremo, Muthavel Karunanidhi is putting necessary pressure on the Indian government to view the matter as seriously as it demands; or that the opposition is demanding similar actions citing failure of state government.

Politics has come to such a level in India that one is aghast to see that the number of MPs DMK provides to ruling Indian coalition government is the gauge of the amount of pressure that may be effective to stir our central government.

How sad! Irrespective of the number of MPs or the communities of the people concerned, the Indian government should always take up matters such as this with the utmost concern.

We Indians must see them as Indians first, Tamil or other identities next. And all of India demands that the Indian government do the needful because of such loss of Indian lives at others' hands can't be tolerated and must be stopped - whatever be the situation.

We in India don't learn. Take, for example a similar incident, though different in many aspects, of the British troops taken as hostages by the Iranian forces along the Shatt-al-Arab, where clarity on whose territory the incident happened is murkier due to historical reasons, claims and counter-claims. However, it must be noted that none of those captured were physically harmed and one can be reasonably certain that they would be freed without any physical harm sooner or later, once the egos of the two states get amply sated.

For India, this is not the first. A series of such reports hit us from Tamil Nadu alone in last couple of months. Before that there were reports of such killings of Indian nationals in the hands of Bangladesh Rifles (BDR), or others.

We in India should not at all have a posture of threatening our neighbors; rather we should seek the status of healthy neighborhood status for mutual benefits and developments. However what can't be ignored is India seldom gets that respect from its neighboring states that India deserves. The failure of it needs to be squarely shared by our own government.

We demand an absolute stop of such incidents, and a thorough accountability for this mishap that killed another four in its latest round to be established and the guilty punished - be through diplomatic means or others. They are Indians after all, and today if we don't stand united, when would we? If need be, the matter needs to be raised in UN to embarrass the guilty. Truly, this extreme possibility needs to be reserved.

We fully understand and empathize with the government of Sri Lanka and its people and broadly with all peace loving people in their effort to take on terrorism. However poor Indian fishermen can not be used as pawns in their battles.

We also demand that the Indian government and the Sri Lankan government, after bringing the guilty to book, adequately compensate those fishermen who lost their near-and-dear and earning members. And if the situation remains that fluid in the territorial waters between India and Sri Lanka in that area in the near future, the government should immediately advise fishermen not to venture out into the sea. And as that means they would lose their livelihood for those few days, the cost of that should be borne by respective governments again by paying them upfront compensations for those many days or months.

We hope we act as a nation, and stop politicians' efforts to play politics over caste, state of origin or language or by the number of MPs they offer for the central government to stay in power. One billion Indians stand firm in their commitment to Tamil fishermen today. Hope our government also does that.

Ranjit is a Research Scholar with Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur, India; and is the author of the book Wondering Man, Money & Go(l)d. He can be reached at ranjit.goswami@gmail.com
eXTReMe Tracker
Keep reading for comments on this article and add some feedback of your own!

Comments! Feedback! Speak and be heard!

Comment on this article or leave feedback for the author

#1
Sanjay
April 2, 2007
11:08 PM

Hey, how about Karunanidhi standing with the nation in demanding that the mastermind behind the bomb assassination of an Indian Prime minister be apprehended and put on trial?

#2
kela
April 2, 2007
11:16 PM

Karuanidhi the great poet cum barber

#3
Sanjay
April 3, 2007
12:52 AM

Barber? He's fleecing the people.

#4
Ajay
April 5, 2007
03:27 AM

Can you cite these reports that say 'tamil fishermen' were killed? In the article you have provided, it clearly says 'Tamilnadu fishermen' were attacked. I dont see why you should have a problem with that statement, also the same article says 'naval vessels surrounded and fired upon Indian fishermen'.

#5
Ranjit Goswami
URL
April 5, 2007
03:53 AM

Tamil Nadu MPs seek PM's intervention in fishermen killings http://www.dailyindia.com/show/124267.php/Tamil-Nadu-MPs-seek-PMs-intervention-in-fishermen-killings

Tamil fishermen targeted by Sri Lanka Navy: MPs http://www.theindiancatholic.com/newsread.asp?nid=6609

There was more of TV news and discussions (if i am not mistaken, on 31st March night when the new incident of four more killings were reported) which I was primarily refering at by various reports. Most reports looked at it nationally, and few tried to give it a political color.

#6
Ajay
April 5, 2007
04:14 AM

Ranjit, thanks for the links. I agree with what you say broadly in the article about being Indians first. I might be reading too much into your lines so forgive me if I sound too analytical.
I dont understand your statement saying "I found that many of them (newspapers) state that those who lost their lives were 'Tamil fishermen'".

In the first link you posted above it clearly quotes T.R Baalu saying "they are continuing their unprovoked shooting-spree on the Indian fishermen." thats as nationalistic as they can get. You also say that "We Indians must see them as Indians first, Tamil or other identities next", its clear from the articles you sent (except for the indian catholic one) that we definetly DO see them as Indians first.
So is this just a case of stating the obvious? If you had cited reports which treated the situation frivolously because it was 'tamil fishermen' and were dismissive about it then I can see your point.

#7
Ranjit Goswami
URL
April 5, 2007
08:04 AM

Hi Ajay,

One thing, though a bit irritating for any writer, which I appreciate in your arguments very much is grilling every words and sentences that we, as readers' demand. We shouldn't accept writers for anything because we, as readers also, do know. And my sincere thanks here for your persistence. Because when I am in your shoes, I show that same demanding persistence that you now expect from me.

I already stated that the primary idea of the article came while viewing news over TV over that night (which TV channel? I switch amongst three prime domestic private English channels). Well, then one can argue my usage of the word 'report' was wrong - I would concede 'defeat' here if one so desires (without seeing that as a 'defeat' as I see it as a learning and also as a society moving to what we desire).

Moreover in most sites (web 2.0), any submitted article goes through editorial value additions. The same posting, when I submitted in my blog didn't have the link (with 'report' word) because it was that 'generic TV news' feeling which I wanted to refer at. Editorial value additions always help us; however there can also be communication gaps, more so over web.

I thank you again for your interest and time.

#8
AnArch
April 5, 2007
08:07 AM

The question here is not the word 'report' but the core thesis of your article that the media and reports refer to them as 'Tamil' and not 'Indian' fishermen - the links provide seem to indicate otherwise.

#9
Thamilan
April 14, 2007
12:54 PM

End of Sinhalese Nationlism or the Sinhalese Race?

The book of Mahavamsa is a work of an idiot. The Sinhalese failure to look beyond that book will bring the total destruction of the whole race. Even the book says that the so called Sinhalese Kings continuously married bride from the Pandiyan Empire in order keep alliance. This makes the so called Sinhalese King more part of the Dravidian blood line. Tamils had the first naval empire of the Indian subcontinent and its laughable that the Sinhalese claim to be on the island before the Tamils. LTTE is just asking for the rights of the Tamil and if they wanted to just to be a terrorist group they would have killed the Sinhalese in Millions by now. LTTE would have never existed if they did not have a reason and would have never been able to fight an outnumbered Army that is well financed for almost 3 decades (also taking on the Indian Army in the middle). When Indians took up arms against the British they were called trouble makers (now it is defined as terrorists). When Blacks demanded their rights from the White South African Government they were also called terrorists. Tamil Nationalism is a very minimum goal of LTTE and the rights of the Tamils of Elam is their main goal. If LTTE fails, the Sinhalese Government will definitely wipe out the Tamils of Elam and that would make Tamil Nationalism to reemerge. Tamil Nadu will for sure wipe the Island of Lanka clean of the Sinhalese if that ever happens. Tamil Nadu buried the Tamil Nationalism for the union of India, if the Central Government of India fails to bring a solution that would be acceptable by Elam Tamils then for sure the break up of Tamil Nadu from the Indian Union is a fact (by force or by referendum). LTTE made a huge mistake by not claiming the whole Island and not labeling Sinhalese as foreigners. The Tamils existence is so rooted into the Island that it cannot be even traced back, while the Sinhalese existence beings with an idiot and his followers being banished from the Bengal. The burning of the Jaffna library which housed scripts and 10,000 years of Tamil history is for sure one of the greatest lost to the Tamils. For sure the two light Air Planes are nothing compared to the Sri Lankan Air Force, but for sure it was enough to make the Sri Lankan Government tremble. The same was said when the Tigers Naval unit emerged and now they proved to be a successful fighting force. If the LTTE gains their goal it is win, win and win situation (for the Tamils, Sinhalese and Indians). If LTTE fails it will be a disaster for the Indian Union and the entire Sinhalese race. Two and a half million Tamils against the sixteen million Sinhalese has only caused the total destruction of the Sinhalese State (bad image on the world stage, ruined economy that is running on donations from the western powers). Seventy million Tamils against the sixteen million Sinhalese will only lead to the extinction of the Sinhalese Race. Tamil Nationalism is far more extreme then the Sinhalese Nationalism.

Add your comment

(Or ping: http://desicritics.org/tb/4914)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.






Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!