REVIEW

Rang De Basanti - Inquilab Zindabad! - Well, The Rebel Has Arrived

January 28, 2006
The Comic Project

"Inquilab Zindabad - Well, The rebel has arrived." That sentence pretty much sums up the film for me.

The Characters:

A documentary filmmaker:
Sue McKinley - who's apparently grown up on her grandfather's diary where he, a jailor during the British Rule in India, presides over the execution of freedom fighters saying "Is this god's work?". She comes to India to shoot her documentary on Bhagat Singh, Chandrashekhar Azad, Ramprasad Bismil, Ashfaqullah. despite her TV channel pulling the plug. She responds to her producer in a unique way that will make the theatre burst out in laughter.

Six Friends:

Ajay Rathod: Flight Lieutnant, who has never done a thing wrong in his life. Loves the cool jackets, honour and the girls that get attracted to his uniform but wants to serve the country in a Mig-29. Sonia's boyfriend.

Aslam Urf Ashfaqullah: Poetic, Idealistic, Romantic. Paints graffitti. From a family that thinks they are a minority and the country is "un logo ke liye", asks him to make friends among their "Quom". Tells his brother that he can't live with hatred in his heart.

DJ, Urf Daljit Singh, Urf Chandrashekhar Azad: Carefree. Under the influence of beer admits "I passed out 5 years ago, but I like being in the campus. Because people know me. Respect me. Say that DJ will do something. But little do they know that in the outside world, a thousand DJs are lost in the grind of life every day."

Karan Singhania, Urf Bhagat Singh: Disillusioned son of a very very rich man and doesn't get along with his father. Most cynical of the lot. Always talking about how the country can never change. Lends money to a friend and says "Baap ka paisa hai. Pade pade sad jaayega"

Sonia Urf Durga Bhabhi: Sue's friend who helps her in making the documentary. Brave and proud, Idealistic but seems to be practical. The baby of the group apparently.

Sukhi, Urf Rajguru: Funny, the joker of the pack. When he is not making funny faces, he worries about getting married. Can't live without DJ.

Lakshman Pande, Urf Ram Prasad Bismil: A political activist. Right-wing, trishul-dhari type political activist. Considers Aslam a Pakistani. Firebrand, idealistic, refuses money from his party leader who persuades him to keep the money for his kharcha.

It is a movie about the filmmaker, "her" freedom fighters and contemporary India. Their carefree life. Latenight beer drinking parties at "the classroom". Dilliwallahs, when you see the film, tell me what this place is please. Between "Sue kar, mere man ko kiya tune kya ishara", Sukhi's antics, Karan's cynical comments, Aslam's poetic predictions after reading Sue's palm and a couple of fights with Lakshman Pande, they start making the transition into Sue's freedom fighters. At first not taking anything seriously, they seem to understand slowly what it must have meant to the freedom fighters to do what they did.

The camaraderie between the friends reminds one of Dil Chahta Hai but it is much more than that. The director takes us on a trip of these friends changing from "carefree, irreverent and cynical" to "purposeful and passionate". The use of sepia-toned scenes to show each of these 6 friends getting into the skin of their respective characters as freedom fighters is impressive. There are no desh bhakti wala dialogues, no ear shattering screams (think Sunny Deol). And while they slowly understand the magnitude of what these freedom fighters did, tragedy strikes. The Defence Minister utters something absolutely indefensible. And if the first part of the movie is about the matter-of-factly, irreverent and cool: "Well, the rebel has arrived", the second part of the movie is an angry, helpless but passionate "Inquilab Zindabad".

The film is NOT only about Aamir Khan and it is not as if he has the best lines. He does a great job in a film where all other characters are given equal screen time. His breakdown at the dinner table while taking a bite of chapatti is most realistic. Atul Kulkarni, his recital of "sarfaroshi ki tamanna" is soul-stirring. He seems to be getting right-wingy roles but does a great job. Sharman Joshi holds his own against the rest of the gang, his outburst towards the end almost shakes one out of the seats. Soha Ali Khan is wonderful too, no overacting, displays the right emotions at the right time and breaks down in a way which makes you feel her pain. Kunal Kapoor, does a good job of being a misfit among his "Quom", great screen presence and a couple of good movies is going to have a huge female fan following. The british actress (what's her name?) mouths the best hindi uttered by a "gora" after Tom Alter. She is earnest and plays her part oh-so-perfectly. But the one I liked the most is this guy called Siddharth. I don't know who this guy is, but at times you wonder if he is actually acting. His quiet voice betrays the angst within him. He needs to work on his crying I guess, but his role demanded something and he has delivered.

The support cast in the form of R Madhavan, Om Puri, Waheeda Rehman, Kirron Kher, Anupam Kher, KK Raina (took me a while to recognize him) and Mohan Agashe do their respective roles as required and have exactly as much screen time as required.

This is not the Manoj Kumar-Sunny Deol type of patriotism nor the Lagaan-Mangal Pande type. No jingoism. If I try to draw a parallel with Yuva, I'd be dead wrong. The patriotism is subtle and not in-your-face. This is a brilliant movie. Brilliant script, fantastic acting, music that blends into the film and the best climax I have seen in years. It is the kind of movie where you desperately want to know what happens in the next scene before you completely understand the one that's playing. And both scenes hit you like sledgehammers at either side of your head.

It has its flaws but anyone who pans this movie should be shot. The movie reflects the state of the nation in a crude but effective way when DJ says "We have one leg on the past and one leg on the future, and we are peeing on the present".

Rakyesh Mehra - Take a bow!!!

This review has appeared earlier on my blog, which has a rather select audience :-)

eXTReMe Tracker
Keep reading for comments on this article and add some feedback of your own!

Rang De Basanti - Inquilab Zindabad! - Well, The Rebel Has Arrived

Article

Author: The Comic Project

 

Comments! Feedback! Speak and be heard!

Comment on this article or leave feedback for the author

#1
Chetan
URL
January 28, 2006
12:05 PM

It has its flaws but anyone who pans this movie should be shot.

LOL! You sure seemed to be inspired by the movie a lot. Talking about shooting and all. Only thing is going by the response it received in the theatre I watched, you would have to shoot more than 300 people. And that is just in one theatre mind you. Flaws my foot! It has glaring holes that gape at you and you want to jump in them. Anything but bear that crap.

They have shamed the memory of airforce pilot Abhijeet Gadgil and his mom, on whom the plot is loosely based by their absolute juveline and screwed up concept. Read about her online and see how she used civil society, the media and her conviction in her son to demand answers from George Fernandes and force the IAF to acknowledge the problem.

In the movie you are gushing so much about one stop feeling outraged at the corruption and the poignant issue and keep cursing the stupidity of the protagonists and the director who in an era of sting operation et al go about that foolishness. (Frankly I dont mind revealing the plot. I think I will save a lot of people their hard earned money. But then what the heck let people know the levels of stupidity a cinema touted as 'intelligent' by most reviewers can stoop to.)

The movie could have gone anywhere after the interval. Just like Aks Mehra ruined the post-interval session. Not that pre-interval session was any good but at least it had enough dough to sustain interest.

#2
Suyog
URL
January 28, 2006
02:40 PM

Chetan has said everything I wanted to say. Incidentally, that is exactly what I and chetan were discussing when saw the movie last night hehe!!

Suyog

#3
Kishan
February 20, 2006
02:07 AM

When i watched Rang de Basanti during the 1st part. I liked it a lot and told myself finally a movie to wake up the lazy youth of this country and put themselves back on track with the country's rapid progress..The second was the opposite of the first a vague theme and not well defined...very badly written and doesnt touch the core of teh subject and contained so many defects and flaws...The Minister of Defence is Responsible for all Affairs in his ministry inlcuding but assasinating the 3rd most important man in the country for a air crash, death of a pilot and a few family and friend emotions does'nt justify destabilizing and assasinating the minister..and besides minister doesn'nt make these decisons...The assasination scene was such a mess up...The Minister of Defence has a 3-ring security consisting of local police,Armed State police and State reserve police...Second ring Parlimentrary forces and Senior Officials and 3rd ring consisting of The N.S.G which is now replaced by The CISF and When they would ve planned the assaination...not to mention the intelligence agencies would've pikced them up.Killing Mod is not killing a bird...Point to note after every air crash they're top level enquiry committee's formed and investigation is carried on and the first report needs to be filed within 3 days the second within 7...And I've nt Heard a Single Blame put on 'josh" of the young pilots...And if you think some wrong was done then you can appeal to the Judicary Which has complete autonomy from Judicary...The movie just shows how ill-informed the youth and our film makers are...Who sends Parliamentary forces to lathi charge that too with the full view of national Electronic media...I've always considered the Govt.of.India PR very good...And this country isnt going to the dogs...We are the fastest growing country after China...People forget lifting people from rags isnt A one day game ...it takes time and generations


This movie Absolutely dint make any sense...I dint watch the ending i was so sick of it

#4
kaveetaa
URL
February 20, 2006
03:36 AM

Chetan, suyog, kishan..Valid criticisms. Agree wholly. Add to that the slip shod manner the Finance Minister was shot, sauntering on the road:)How convenient can the script writers make the most crucial depiction of the film!!

#5
kaveetaa
URL
February 20, 2006
04:02 AM

Errata: read Defence Minister.

#6
gaurav
February 22, 2006
02:01 PM

i enjoyed the movie, even though you guys have correctly described quite a few loop holes, film making i guess is all about taking a story plot from some where and adding to it what the script writer thinks should happen.
The movie should not be exactly what happens or happened in real life and i think the idea was creative. (Much better than directly picking up a cheap hollywood script or dishing out another love thing.
i dont care about how the defence minister was shot or what his security is all i care about is do i have fun while watching it and will i watch it again, the answer to that is yes.
and i dont believe that movies or something can "wake up the lazy youth of this country and put themselves back on track" (if they really are crazy)
Final Verdict from me: Dont think too much about the intricacies, go and enjoy it.

#7
Jane
May 8, 2006
09:47 AM

The first time I watched the movie, I thought it was a good movie - yes, there are loopholes, but the script has prepared us that these young people care about each other very much, and alos that they risk their lives without thinking about it, just for fun. When tragedy strikes, these are the motivations that carry them in the direction that they take, together with having gotten "inside" the characters in Sue's film, as she directs them to do.

The acting was splendid, especially Aamir Khan and Siddarth. The film would benefit from some tightening, perhaps 15-20 minutes, but altogether a stunning job. When I watched it the second time, I knew it was a great film

Add your comment



Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.






Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!